When a repair makes sense, when replacement is the honest call, and how to tell the difference.
The answer usually comes down to the posts. Boards and pickets are easy to swap; posts are the fence’s foundation.
Push on the posts. If they’re firm and the fence just needs boards or a gate fix, repair. If posts wobble or lean across several sections, replacement usually costs less than chasing repairs, and it’s the chance to fix what the last installer got wrong.
Grab a post near the middle of a run and try to rock it at head height. Solid means you likely have a repair. Movement at the base, or a soft spongy feel right at grade, means the post is going and the boards attached to it are on borrowed time.
Then walk the line and count. Damage confined to one or two spots is a repair almost regardless of the fence age. Problems appearing evenly along the whole run point at the original build, and no amount of spot work fixes a build.
Posts are sound and only pickets or rails are damaged. A vehicle or a fallen limb hit one section. A single gate has dropped. The fence is under about ten years old and the trouble is localised. Storm damage to an otherwise healthy fence, which is also the case most likely to be covered by a claim.
Multiple posts are loose, rotted at grade, or leaning the same direction. You are repairing the same run for the second or third time. More than roughly a third of the fence needs work. The posts are undersized or were never set in concrete. Or you want a different height or style, in which case patching the old one is spending money to keep something you do not want.
Plenty of fences are ten to fifteen years old with a few bad sections and the rest holding. Three questions settle it.
How long are you staying? Two years and twenty years are different answers on the same fence.
What did the last repair cost, and when? Repairs that keep recurring are the fence telling you.
Will a repair match? New cedar next to twelve year old grey cedar does not blend, and it will not for years.
A partial replacement is often the honest answer: rebuild the failing runs properly, leave the sound ones, and accept a visible colour difference for a season or two.
If the posts are sound, yes, replacing boards and hardware is far cheaper than a full rebuild. Once posts fail across the run, replacement wins.
Rock the post at head height. Movement at the base, or wood that feels soft right at grade, means the post is failing even if the pickets look fine.
Repair costs less today. Whether it costs less over the years you own the house depends on the posts. Repairs to a fence with failing posts rarely carry forward.
Yes, and it is often the sensible call. Expect a visible colour difference between new and weathered wood that takes a couple of seasons to close up.
Sudden accidental damage such as a storm or a vehicle is generally covered. Age, rot, and deferred maintenance are not. Photograph the damage before anything is repaired.
Owner on every job · in-house crews · written warranty
Request an estimate